dougwilsonsays.com

Contending for the Faith in Moscow, Idaho

Doug Wilson Says Pedophiles Should Be Put to ‘Death’ but the Penalty for the Pedophile in My Church Should Be ‘Measured and Limited’

(Updated on ) | Opinion by
Pedophiles Should Be Put to Death

“But when we are dealing with young children who are abused by adults (pederasty, child porn, etc.) the penalty for those guilty of the crime should be death.”1 — Doug Wilson

“I am grateful Steven was caught, and am grateful he has been brought to account for these actions so early in his life. I am grateful that he will be sentenced for his behavior, and that there will be hard consequences for him in real time. At the same time, I would urge that the civil penalties applied would be measured and limited. I have a good hope that Steven has genuinely repented, and that he will continue to deal with this to become a productive and contributing member of society.”2 —Doug Wilson (in a letter to a judge regarding convicted pedophile Steven Sitler)


OPINION: The controversy regarding the convicted pedophile Steven Sitler has been well documented over the years.3 Even Wilson’s own denomination has questioned the wisdom of his involvement and counsel in this case.4 Wilson has written that he believes the penalty for convicted pedophiles “should be death”5 and yet when a man who attended his church and was enrolled at his college (New Saint Andrews) was on trial for pedophilia,6 he wrote a letter to the judge that appeared to many as asking for leniency. Wilson has attempted multiple times to explain that “measured and limited” does not mean “trivial, light, or lenient.”7 But given the context, and the contrast between “hard consequences” and “measured and limited,” I do not believe that his words can be interpreted as anything other than Wilson asking for leniency from the judge.8 But even if we accept Wilson’s later definitions, a contradiction remains. If Wilson was being consistent with his belief—that pedophiles should be put to death—a letter to the judge would have asked for the highest penalty possible under the law. Instead, he asked for a “measured and limited” penalty. Such a request, quoting Wilson’s own denomination, “. . . is the kind of thing that can lead to a lot of heartache for victims and their families.”9

Yet Wilson continues to defend himself. Even while accepting responsibility for any “friends” who “missed” his meaning, his posture is one of innocence rather than culpability.10 He fails to acknowledge the greater sins: the harm he may have caused to the victims by his apparent support of their abuser, and the damage done to the name of Christ among unbelievers due to his actions.

The mishandling of this abuse case, along with Wilson’s refusal to humble himself and admit his failure, is one reason he has such a poor reputation in the community here in Moscow.11 I believe it is also another reason he does not meet the biblical qualifications for an elder (1 Timothy 3:7). His actions are those of someone who is two-faced, calling for the death penalty on the one hand, but on the other, when a man who attended his church and was enrolled at one of his schools was charged, appealing for leniency12 from the judge, hoping that he would not “lose his temper”13 or “make a determination based upon the faulty assumption that’s in the air about pedophiles—you might as well take them out and shoot them.”14

Subscribe for Updates

Get all the latest posts directly in your inbox.

You’ll receive an email to confirm your subscription.

What of the victims? What of justice? Wouldn’t it have been right for Sitler to accept the highest penalty under the law in order to show that he understood his sin, the heinous nature of it, as well as seek to show true sorrow over his sins to his victims? As the thief on the cross confessed: “Do you not fear God, since you are under the same sentence of condemnation? And we indeed justly, for we are receiving the due reward of our deeds” (Luke 23:40–41). But instead, it seems clear that Wilson minimized Sitler’s sin at the expense of the victims, and by doing so, heaped more hurt on them as well as damaged his own testimony in his local community. Such a stance also harmed Sitler, for by minimizing his sin, it interfered with his own repentance toward God and those he harmed. Years later, Sitler would be back in court because there were major concerns over the safety of his son (he had married and had a son by this time), and Wilson’s actions in the controversy were again decried locally.15

This seems to be a pattern with Wilson: minimizing the sin of the perpetrator while often ignoring the needs of the victims.16 This is contrary to the character of God, who is the defender of the weak and oppressed: “‘Because the poor are plundered, because the needy groan, I will now arise,’ says the Lord; ‘I will place him in the safety for which he longs’” (Psalm 12:5). And “Execute justice in the morning, and deliver from the hand of the oppressor him who has been robbed, lest my wrath go forth like fire, and burn with none to quench it, because of your evil deeds” (Jeremiah 21:12).

Is there forgiveness in Christ for pedophiles? Yes! But repentance doesn’t mean trying to make less of your sin and seeking an easy way out, as Sitler appears to have done—accepting a plea deal by disclosing his other victims with the promise that the state would not charge him “with any other crimes of a similar nature to Lewd Conduct with a Minor Under Sixteen Years of Age.”17 And there were many victims, according to Bill Thompson, the prosecutor on Sitler’s case:

“He is a serial child sexual abuser to the point where Your Honor has imposed a life sentence and required that he be under supervision for the rest of his natural life. He has multiple victims, all of them young, some so young that they would not be in any position to protect themselves.”18

Our prayer is that rather than continue to defend himself, Wilson would humbly and clearly admit that he was wrong to protect Sitler and minimize his sin at the expense of the victims and their families. We pray that he would acknowledge how his actions have caused the name of Christ to be defamed here locally, and that he would humbly seek forgiveness of the victims and their families, of Sitler, and of the local community.

NOTE: Abuse within churches is sadly a common occurrence, and is often mishandled by church leaders. This is not unique to Wilson. The main difference between Wilson and his church, Christ Church, and other churches within the CREC, is that when the abuse is discovered, Wilson and his church tend to side more strongly with the perpetrator (usually a man)—in the courtroom, in letters asking for reduced sentencing, in speaking excessively of forgiveness toward the offender—but then accusing the victim of bitterness, gossip, slander and lies, thus retraumatizing the victim (usually a woman) over and over again. This is particularly harmful, as the victim is being attacked by those claiming to have God’s authority, and therefore the spiritual abuse, in addition to the other abuses, is often catastrophic. This devastating pattern has been described by many witnesses.19

Want More Context?

Here are some links to other blogs and podcasts dealing with this issue in more depth:

A 499-page report by an ex-CREC member, Rachel L. Shubin on two specific cases, including Sitler’s: https://web.archive.org/web/20230507061929/https://www.moscowid.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Analyzing-DWs-Response-to-Sitler-and-Wight-Cases.pdf

Tony, Kalina, and Kallie: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-L5vGvrhjs

Anonymous Woman and Theresa Smith: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zSqY_1hYXg

Hayley McCord and Anonymous Woman: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wgyEQAo6K2Q

Holly Rench and Kathy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvbw967Z-dw

Anonymous Man: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tpSguas8gDw

https://www.theamericanconservative.com/douglas-wilson-steven-sitler-pride/

https://heidelblog.net/2023/07/hohn-cho-on-missing-the-point-of-sexual-abuse/

https://www.theamericanconservative.com/scandal-in-moscow/

https://spiritualsoundingboard.com/2015/09/04/pastor-doug-wilson-a-serial-pedophile-and-the-real-victims/

https://web.archive.org/web/20240127125210/https://www.christkirk.com/crec-presiding-ministers-report-2017/

https://bredenhof.ca/2023/07/03/doug-wilson-the-bad/

https://bredenhof.ca/2023/07/10/doug-wilson-the-ugly/

Footnotes

Footnotes

  1. Douglas Wilson, Fidelity: How to Be a One-Woman Man (Canon Press, 2012), 77, Kindle edition. ↩

  2. Douglas Wilson to Judge John R. Stegner, regarding Steven Sitler, August 19, 2005, archived February 29, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240229092657/https://sitler.moscowid.net/2005/08/19/douglas-wilson-to-judge-stegner-i-have-been-asked-to-provide-a-letter-on-behalf-of-steven-sitler-which-i-am-happy-to-do/; see also Douglas Wilson, “An Open Letter from Christ Church on Steven Sitler,” Blog & Mablog, September 5, 2015, archived August 15, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240815174537/https://dougwils.com/books-and-culture/s7-engaging-the-culture/an-open-letter-from-christ-church-on-steven-sitler.html. ↩

  3. See https://web.archive.org/web/20250808063404/https://www.patheos.com/blogs/lovejoyfeminism/2015/09/doug-wilsons-pedophile-problem-the-root-of-the-issue.html; https://web.archive.org/web/20220809092117/https://moscowid.net/2015/09/07/the-truth-about-steven-sitler/; https://web.archive.org/web/20250808044212/https://www.theamericanconservative.com/doug-wilson-reluctant-response/; https://web.archive.org/web/20250808051012/https://theaquilareport.com/doug-wilsons-failure-to-safeguard-children/; and https://web.archive.org/web/20211006164439/http://sitler.moscowid.net/12084-2/. ↩

  4. Specifically regarding Wilson’s letter to the judge, the presiding ministers’ report states: “We are satisfied that what Pastor Wilson meant was, in light of all the circumstances, including Sitler’s self-disclosure and acceptance of responsibility, that the sentencing judge would not just put Sitler in prison and throw away the key. Nevertheless, a recommendation from a pastor for a ‘measured and limited’ sentence for a serial child molester, whatever the intentions, is the kind of thing that can lead to a lot of heartache for victims and their families, and a lot of confusion by the public. It would have been wiser for Pastor Wilson to simply stick to communicating about the facts of the case as he was familiar with them, and let the judge do his job of determining an appropriate sentence under current law.” Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches, Presiding Ministers’ Report on the Sitler and Wight Sex Abuse Cases, presented to Christ Church, Moscow, Idaho, August 15, 2017, archived March 2, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240302091340/https://www.christkirk.com/crec-presiding-ministers-report-2017/ (also archived at https://web.archive.org/web/20250705234156/https://moscowid.net/communion-of-reformed-evangelical-churches-presiding-ministers-report-on-the-sitler-and-wight-sex-abuse-cases/). ↩

  5. Wilson reiterated this view as recently as 2022: “It would be just in a hypothetical biblical republic five hundred years from now, it would be just and appropriate if a pedophile, upon being convicted of, you know, raping little children, uh, execution would be entirely just, entirely righteous.” All My Friends Are Heretics, “Episode 1: Douglas Wilson—Pedophiles, Justice, and the Gospel,” YouTube video, premiered March 25, 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TEpsoQqfWtk, 2:03. And if Wilson believes it would be righteous five hundred years from now, it also would be righteous now, and he is just affirming what he already wrote in the original quote. ↩

  6. Technically the legal conviction was for “Lewd Conduct with a Minor Under Sixteen Years of Age,” but he was also diagnosed “as a fixated pedophile in 2005 who ‘under no circumstances should be allowed to be around children unsupervised.’” Plea agreement, State v. Sitler, Latah County Case No. CR-2005-02027, archived May 16, 2022, https://web.archive.org/web/20220516153112/http://www.tomandrodna.com/CR_2005_02027/Plea_Agreement.pdf; and https://web.archive.org/web/20210310052938/https://sitler.moscowid.net/2015/12/17/idoc-to-judge-stegner/. ↩

  7. “By ‘measured and limited,’ I meant principled, defined and deliberate. I did not mean trivial, light, or lenient.” Wilson, “An Open Letter from Christ Church on Steven Sitler”; and “I wanted the judge to not lose his temper.” All My Friends Are Heretics, “Episode 1,” 21:39ff. ↩

  8. If we replace the original words Wilson used with the words he said convey his true meaning, notice that his request still attempts to seek penalties less than the maximum allowed by law: “I am grateful that he will be sentenced for his behavior, and that there will be hard consequences for him in real time. At the same time, I would urge that the civil penalties applied would be [principled, defined and deliberate]” (text of letter taken from: https://web.archive.org/web/20250808044212/https://www.theamericanconservative.com/doug-wilson-reluctant-response/). Wilson purportedly wrote another letter in 2005 regarding another abuse case that also seems to advocate for the normal sense of the terms “measured and limited” for the perpetrator: “We have told him that it is appropriate for him to obtain legal representation in order to ensure that his legal and civil rights are fully respected, and to ensure that the punishment given to him is not draconian or disproportionate” (text of letter taken from: https://web.archive.org/web/20250822122031/http://wight.moscowid.net/2005/08/douglas-wilson-to-officer-green/). See also Rachel Green Miller, “Doug Wilson: ‘I am not defending the rapist,’” A Daughter of the Reformation, November 11, 2015, archived August 8, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250808051025/https://rachelgreenmiller.wordpress.com/2015/11/11/doug-wilson-i-am-not-defending-the-rapist/. ↩

  9. CREC, Presiding Ministers’ Report. ↩

  10. Wilson writes: “My apologies to any friends who missed my meaning here, and who thought I was trying to trim and be cute on Steven’s behalf. Such a misreading would be my responsibility.” Douglas Wilson, “The Only Kind of Gospel There Is,” Blog & Mablog, September 10, 2015, archived December 2, 2023, https://web.archive.org/web/20231202052531/https://dougwils.com/books-and-culture/s7-engaging-the-culture/the-only-kind-of-gospel-there-is.html. ↩

  11. I have not lived in another town where a pastor and his church appear to have such a widely discussed and frequently criticized public reputation—not because of the gospel message, but because of allegations of mishandled abuse scandals and a perceived hostility toward non-Christians. Readers may examine these public discussions and form their own conclusions about how Doug Wilson and Christ Church are regarded within the broader community: Moscow-Pullman Daily News Facebook comment threads, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.facebook.com/profile/100063757173550/search/?q=Christ%20Church; Tracy Simmons, “Controversial Church Aims to ‘Make Moscow a Christian Town,’” The Spokesman-Review, November 17, 2019, archived September 5, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250905171042/https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2019/nov/17/leaders-of-moscows-christ-church-say-theyre-pushin/; Alex Brizee, “25 Years of Christ Church on UI’s Campus,” The Argonaut, February 5, 2020, updated May 18, 2020, archived February 18, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250218165115/https://www.uiargonaut.com/2020/02/05/25-years-of-christ-church-on-uis-campus/; Nick Gier, “Doug Wilson,” University of Idaho, n.d., archived April 29, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250429022416/https://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/ngier/Wilson.htm; Hohn Cho, “On the Importance of Reputation,” Heidelblog, July 21, 2023, archived May 21, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250521212459/https://heidelblog.net/2023/07/on-the-importance-of-reputation/; Examining Doug Wilson & Moscow, Idaho, “A Timeline of Controversial Pastor Douglas Wilson of Moscow, Idaho,” Facebook, December 5, 2020, accessed June 24, 2025, https://www.facebook.com/ExaminingMoscow/posts/a-timeline-of-controversial-pastor-douglas-wilson-of-moscow-idaho-mid-1960s-doug/227255002157456/. ↩

  12. Even if we grant Wilson’s later definition of the terms he wrote, he at least asked for less than the maximum allowable penalty under the law, which is a type of leniency. ↩

  13. Wilson says in a 2022 interview: “I wanted the judge to not lose his temper.” All My Friends Are Heretics, “Episode 1,” 21:39ff. ↩

  14. All My Friends Are Heretics, “Episode 1,” 23:37. Wilson’s own denomination understood Wilson’s words in the letter as follows: “We are satisfied that what Pastor Wilson meant was, in light of all the circumstances, including Sitler’s self-disclosure and acceptance of responsibility, that the sentencing judge would not just put Sitler in prison and throw away the key. Nevertheless, a recommendation from a pastor for a ‘measured and limited’ sentence for a serial child molester, whatever the intentions, is the kind of thing that can lead to a lot of heartache for victims and their families, and a lot of confusion by the public. It would have been wiser for Pastor Wilson to simply stick to communicating about the facts of the case as he was familiar with them, and let the judge do his job of determining an appropriate sentence under current law.” CREC, Presiding Ministers’ Report. ↩

  15. Samantha Malott, “Prosecutor: New Disclosures of Conduct by Moscow Sex Offender Are ‘State’s Worst Fears,’” Moscow-Pullman Daily News, September 2, 2015, archived February 18, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250218165721/https://www.dnews.com/local-news-northwest/prosecutor-new-disclosures-of-conduct-by-moscow-sex-offender-are-states-worst-fears4e009e14. ↩

  16. Rachel Shubin, “The Shubin Report: ‘Analyzing Douglas Wilson’s Handling of the Steven Sitler and Jamin Wight Cases’” (2016), archived August 14, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240814204211/https://heidelblog.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/07141330/Analyzing-DWs-Response-to-Sitler-and-Wight-Cases.pdf; Sarah Stankorb, “Inside the Church That Preaches ‘Wives Need to Be Led with a Firm Hand,’” Vice, September 28, 2021, archived March 15, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240315042429/https://www.vice.com/en/article/m7ezwx/inside-the-church-that-preaches-wives-need-to-be-led-with-a-firm-hand; see also our post “‘You Need to Repent of All the Venomous Comments You Made,’ ‘Directed at Us,’ ‘If You Don’t Repent, You Are Lost Forever’” regarding Wilson’s response to the testimony of these women or online at https://dougwilsonsays.com/blog/make-venomous-comments-about-me-go-to-hell/. ↩

  17. CREC, Presiding Ministers’ Report. ↩

  18. This court proceeding took place in 2015, ten years after the initial proceedings in 2005, after Sitler had married and had a child (the safety of the child was the main concern of this proceeding). The audio recording of the hearing is publicly available, archived November 2, 2019, https://web.archive.org/web/20191102105858/http://www.moscowid.net/tag/latah-county-prosecutor-bill-thompson/. ↩

  19. https://web.archive.org/web/20240315042429/https://www.vice.com/en/article/m7ezwx/inside-the-church-that-preaches-wives-need-to-be-led-with-a-firm-hand See also our post on Wilson’s response to the testimony of these women that includes more firsthand testimonies from other women: https://dougwilsonsays.com/blog/make-venomous-comments-about-me-go-to-hell/ ↩

Subscribe for Updates

Get all the latest posts directly in your inbox.

You’ll receive an email to confirm your subscription.