dougwilsonsays.com

Contending for the Faith in Moscow, Idaho

Doug Wilson Says The ‘Promises Are Apprehended by Faith’ and Also by ‘Works’

(Updated on ) | Opinion by
Faith and Works

“I have argued that promises are apprehended by faith, not faithfulness or fidelity, but, of course, faith in the biblical sense is inseparable from faithfulness. Faith is invisible to the human eye, but faith’s constant companion—faithfulness—is not invisible. Nevertheless, it is faith that receives the promises, overthrows kingdoms, and stops the mouths of lions. If we adopt the shorthand of James, we could say that faithfulness (works) does these things also, but we would be using his shorthand.”1 — Doug Wilson


OPINION: This quote is from “Reformed” Is Not Enough, a book Wilson wrote in 2002 as “something of a response”2 to a charge of teaching Federal Vision, a heretical theology of works-based salvation, which we addressed in another post. He begins his statement with truth—that the promises of God are apprehended through faith, and not works—but then appears to contradict himself by stating that James teaches “that faithfulness (works) does these things also.” (The “works” in the sentence is a direct quote from his book, not my personal interpretation of what Wilson means by faithfulness.) This is a dangerous theological error: We are either saved by grace through faith alone, or we are saved by that plus other things. It cannot be both, despite Wilson’s claims.3

James does not teach that we are saved by works; rather, he declares that we are only saved by faith in Jesus. He contrasts a person who claims they have faith (but does not truly believe) with a person who actually has faith in Jesus. He instructs that we can recognize the difference between the two by the external manifestation of true faith: good works (James 2:14–26).4 Wilson seems to miss the point and conflates faith with good works, rather than clearly stating that works are the result of true faith in Jesus, flowing out of a heart regenerated by the Holy Spirit. And such a mistake is deadly. The gospel is at stake! There is no room for obscurity when God, through the Holy Spirit, makes it abundantly clear: “He saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5). If readers think I am merely misunderstanding Wilson, his daughter Rachel Jankovic, also a published author, has seemingly adopted his unscriptural views. These statements are often sandwiched in between biblical truth, as are Wilson’s various errors, but they can be found in her writings.5

Subscribe for Updates

Get all the latest posts directly in your inbox.

You’ll receive an email to confirm your subscription.

This theological confusion is not merely an academic matter—it obscures the gospel. If Wilson and Jankovic truly believe in salvation by grace alone, as they have both stated in other places, without any contribution of our faithfulness (works), then this continued ambiguity remains irresponsible, especially for Wilson, who has been accused multiple times of theological error regarding the relationship of faith and works. Correctly stating doctrinal truth in one place does not justify teaching doctrinal error in another (John 11:49–52). “A little leaven leavens the whole lump” (Galatians 5:9), and a little poison is lethal.

As already mentioned, two years after publishing “Reformed” Is Not Enough, Wilson agreed, when asked, that his theology’s redefinitions and lack of clarity regarding “justification, Christian, election, salvation, and regeneration” had “caused some to stumble.”6 But to this day he has not removed these errors from his published works, which suggests that he does not consider them serious. When I confronted him about this, it was clear that though he has more recently attempted to distance himself from the label of Federal Vision, he continues to firmly hold to the basic tenets of its teaching.7 He has had more than twenty years to clear up this controversy, and yet it continues. Jesus has choice words for those who cause stumbling: “Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe to stumble, it would be better for him if, with a heavy millstone hung around his neck, he had been cast into the sea” (Mark 9:42, NASB95).

Our prayer is that Wilson will take this warning seriously, bearing fruit in keeping with repentance, pull gospel-distorting books like “Reformed” Is Not Enough from publication, recognize his personal contribution to the spiritual harm of many, and publicly seek forgiveness.

Want More Context?

Here are some links to other blogs and podcasts dealing with this and other issues in more depth:

https://theocast.org/is-doug-wilson-a-false-teacher/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAqhpb-UF40

https://bredenhof.ca/2023/07/03/doug-wilson-the-bad/

https://bredenhof.ca/2023/07/10/doug-wilson-the-ugly/

https://heidelblog.net/2017/10/resources-on-the-controversy-over-final-salvation-through-works/

https://heidelblog.net/fv/

https://jonathanshumate.substack.com/p/federal-vision-in-eve-in-exile

https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/course/justification-faith-biblical-theological-perspective/#a-summary-of-justification-by-faith-from-a-biblical-theological-perspective

https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/course/study-james-moo/

https://www.biblicaltraining.org/learn/institute/nt622-galatians

Footnotes

Footnotes

  1. Douglas Wilson, “Reformed” Is Not Enough, 2nd ed. (Canon Press, 2010), Kindle loc. 2294. When Wilson refers to the “shorthand of James,” I believe he is teaching that James would equate faith with works—that they both accomplish the same “things” (“receives the promises, overthrows kingdoms, and stops the mouths of lions”). ↩

  2. Wilson, “Reformed” Is Not Enough, loc. 53. ↩

  3. Note: The aforementioned quote is from Wilson’s chapter on “Covenant Succession,” and the promises he refers to relate to salvation. See also J. Wesley White, “Saying ‘Justification by Faith Alone’ Isn’t Enough,” Mid-America Journal of Theology 17 (2006): 239–65, archived January 18, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250118132702/https://www.midamerica.edu/uploads/files/pdf/journal/17-white.pdf. ↩

  4. Douglas Moo writes, “Critical to understanding the argument of the section and integrating it successfully into a broader biblical perspective is the recognition that James is not arguing that works must be added to faith. His point, rather, is that genuine biblical faith will inevitably be characterized by works. Trying to add works to a bogus faith is an exercise in futility, for only by ‘accepting the implanted word’ (1:21) and experiencing the inner transformation that it brings can one produce works pleasing to God. James, in a sense, proposes for us in these verses a ‘test’ by which we determine the genuineness of faith: deeds of obedience to the will of God.” Douglas J. Moo, The Letter of James, The Pillar New Testament Commentary (Eerdmans; Apollos, 2000), 120. ↩

  5. One clear example: When responding to controversy over her book You Who?, Jankovic first states the truth that we do not earn our salvation through obedience, but then wrongly equates obedience with faith as her father does: “I do not believe that we earn our salvation with obedience (or with anything), but we do express our salvation through obedience. Faith is a gift. Obedience is a gift. Having faith is obedience, because we are told to have it. Obedience is faith because it is an expression of it. Real faith and obedience go hand in hand.” Rachel Jankovic, “When I shamelessly call women to obedience in You Who . . .,” Facebook, February 28, 2019, https://www.facebook.com/share/14MgJMGXxTc/; see also Kerry Baldwin, “You Who? Rachel Jankovic is Wrong on Identity,” Mere Liberty, archived April 22, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240422064648/https://mereliberty.com/book-reviews/rachel-jankovic-wrong-identity/. ↩

  6. Question 2: “It seems like one result of Federal Vision is blurred definitions of terms that were once clear and thus comforting. Terms such as justification, Christian, election, salvation, and regeneration seem now to be used in ways that are unknown, unclear and discomforting. Are you concerned that you may have contributed to this loss of certitude and comfort, and thus caused some to stumble?” Wilson’s answer: “Yes, I would have to say so. . . .” Confederation of Reformed Evangelical Churches, Minutes of the Eighth Annual Meeting of the Presbytery, October 13–15, 2004, appendix E, archived November 29, 2023, https://web.archive.org/web/20231129180132/https://crechurches.org/documents/minutes/2004crec.pdf. ↩

  7. Douglas Wilson, Against the Church *(*Canon Press, 2013), 54, Kindle edition. He also writes in the same book: “What I have written in this book [Against the Church] does not represent in any way a ‘walking back’ of what I argued there [in ‘Reformed’ Is Not Enough]. Rather, it is a straightforward application of it” (205). ↩

Subscribe for Updates

Get all the latest posts directly in your inbox.

You’ll receive an email to confirm your subscription.