dougwilsonsays.com

Contending for the Faith in Moscow, Idaho

Doug Wilson Says ‘Raise Your Hand If You Knew That the Westminster Confession Taught Baptismal Regeneration’

(Updated on ) | Opinion by
Baptismal Regeneration

“Raise your hand if you knew that the Westminster Confession taught baptismal regeneration. . . . Baptism means that the one baptized has a sign and seal of the covenant of grace, has been grafted into Christ, has the sign and seal of regeneration and forgiveness of sins, and has the obligation to walk in newness of life . . . baptism is efficacious. But the efficacy of the sacrament is not tied to the moment when it is administered. By means of baptism, this efficacious grace is conferred on the elect at the appropriate time, the time of conversion, and it is the applied grace of their baptism.”1 — Doug Wilson


OPINION: Stated simply, baptismal regeneration is the belief “that regeneration is effected in and through Christian baptism.”2 Why would Wilson emphasize that the Westminster Confession teaches baptismal regeneration when he has previously stated that it is a “false and destructive doctrine,”3 even calling it “sub-Christian”?4

The answer lies in the Federal Vision controversy, which we have already discussed at length.5 One of the central critiques of Federal Vision is that it affirms “some version of baptismal regeneration.”6 Wilson denies the charge, but his own words make the denial difficult to sustain. In his church’s baptismal liturgy, Wilson declared that “by baptism, we are initiated into the covenant community and made members of the body of Christ” and instructed parents to consider their baptized infant “as your brother in the Lord, as a joint heir of all God’s covenant blessings.”7 He has written that “contrary to Warfield, baptism is efficacious”8 and that Calvin himself held to baptismal regeneration in a “limited sense.”9 Whatever Wilson calls this, it walks and talks like baptismal regeneration.

Wilson’s defense is to claim he’s in good company—that Calvin and the Westminster Confession itself teach what he teaches. But let me clearly state: Even if the Westminster Confession or John Calvin teaches baptismal regeneration, that teaching should be rejected, not embraced. As Spurgeon said:

“I cry out against it [baptismal regeneration] because I believe that baptism does not save the soul, and that the preaching of it has a wrong and evil influence upon men. . . . How can any man stand up in his pulpit and say ‘Ye must be born again’ to his congregation, when he has already assured them, by his own ‘unfeigned assent and consent’ to it, that they are themselves, every one of them, born again in baptism.”10

Wilson claims he does not believe in baptismal regeneration, and yet at the same time speaks as if there is no problem if he does, since, according to Wilson, other accepted Reformed theologians teach it. This is not a defense. It is confusion.

Subscribe for Updates

Get all the latest posts directly in your inbox.

You’ll receive an email to confirm your subscription.

And while Wilson, in the Joint Federal Vision Statement, tried to distance himself from the term “baptismal regeneration,”11 Wes White observed that “the theology stays the same, but the terminology that would get them in trouble is jettisoned.”12 As previously mentioned, the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) rightly identified the danger:

“Our concern is that some of those who are baptized will simply presume on God’s grace, ‘continuing in the covenant’ without ‘apostatizing’ but also without justifying faith (cf. Matthew 22:1–14); others will be driven to despair, working for a salvation out of ‘covenant faithfulness’ instead of resting and receiving Jesus alone for their salvation.”13

We witnessed firsthand the very concerns the PCA highlighted. Early on, while volunteering for a library reading session in our son’s class at Logos School14—which Wilson helped start15—I read a children’s book by R. C. Sproul. After finishing, I asked the children, “How are we saved?” Almost all the hands shot up, followed immediately with the enthusiastic response of “Baptism!” Surprised, I gently replied, “No . . .” This time, only a few hands were raised, and a child tentatively offered, “By believing in Jesus?” Wilson’s belief that water baptism objectively grafts people into union with Christ could have dangerous consequences.16 A child baptized as an infant in his church who lives a good enough life to not be excommunicated may grow up without understanding their need to place their faith in Jesus for the forgiveness of their sins. Why would they need to? They’ve been baptized, are “united” with Christ, and are considered to be a “joint heir of all God’s covenant blessings.”17 But this is not the gospel. It is not the baptized that are the children of God; rather, “to all who did receive him, who believed in his name, he gave the right to become children of God, who were born, not of blood nor of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man, but of God” (John 1:12–13). And again, “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast” (Ephesians 2:8–9). The gospel is simple enough for a child to understand. But Doug Wilson has distorted the gospel in such a way that children and adults alike could easily be confused.

Our prayer is that Wilson would truly repent of his confusing advocacy of baptismal regeneration by pulling books like “Reformed” Is Not Enough from the shelves, and fully recant the Joint Federal Vision Statement (not just in name).18 And that he would seek forgiveness from all those who have stumbled because of his teaching.

Want More Context?

Here are some links to other blogs and podcasts dealing with this and other issues in more depth:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAqhpb-UF40

https://greenbaggins.wordpress.com/2008/03/14/are-children-assumed-to-be-saved/

https://www.sermonaudio.com/sermons/213232214116948

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jrf1VAVgKU0

https://www.apuritansmind.com/book-reviews/the-black-list-reformed-is-not-enough/

https://reformed.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Federal-Vision-Doug-Wilson-and-Infant-Baptism.pdf

https://heidelblog.net/2013/11/for-those-just-tuning-in-what-is-the-federal-vision/

https://learn.ligonier.org/guides/the-federal-vision

https://www.trinityfoundation.org/PDF/The%20Trinity%20Review%2000221%20251FederalVision.pdf

https://dougwilsonsays.com/blog/declared-to-be-heretics/

https://dougwilsonsays.com/blog/still-affirm-federal-vision/

Footnotes

Footnotes

  1. Douglas Wilson, “Reformed” Is Not Enough, 2nd ed. (Canon Press, 2010), Kindle loc. 1256. ↩

  2. Merriam-Webster, s.v. “baptismal regeneration,” archived August 25, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250825022009/https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/baptismal%20regeneration; see also https://web.archive.org/web/20240827065027/https://carm.org/about-baptism/what-other-errors-does-baptismal-regeneration-promote/; https://youtu.be/tAqhpb-UF40; and https://web.archive.org/web/20250624123648/https://learn.ligonier.org/qas/response-to-baptismal-regeneration. ↩

  3. The complete quote: “In the same way, we need to get to the point where no one would dream of accusing an evangelical paedobaptist of holding to the false and destructive doctrine of baptismal regeneration—even though the Roman Catholic church does.” Douglas Wilson, To a Thousand Generations: Infant Baptism—Covenant Mercy for the People of God (Canon Press, 1996), Kindle loc. 56. ↩

  4. Wilson, To a Thousand Generations, loc. 101. ↩

  5. See our post “We ‘Were Declared to Be Heretics’”. ↩

  6. “Some have charged this view with affirming some version of baptismal regeneration. No doubt, this charge carries some weight if ‘regeneration’ carries the sense it normally does in theology, namely, God’s sovereign and gracious act by the Spirit to make spiritually dead people alive in Christ (see Eph. 2:1–10). Yet, for some advocates of the Federal Vision they redefine regeneration to refer to the entire work of how we are renewed and now partake of the new creation in Christ, including the placement of the elect and non-elect in the covenant community.” Stephen Wellum, “The Federal Vision,” The Gospel Coalition, n.d., archived July 13, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250713042039/https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/essay/the-federal-vision/. ↩

  7. Daniel Foucachon, “Christ Church, Moscow, Idaho Infant Baptisms,” YouTube video, June 3, 2011, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDQfkoHNlBA, 0:17. When I met with Wilson, he told me that he no longer baptizes anyone, and that they now use a different liturgy, but not because of any change in belief. ↩

  8. Wilson, “Reformed” Is Not Enough, loc. 1321. Wilson summarizes at the end of the same chapter by stating: “By means of baptism, baptism with water, grace and salvation are conferred on the elect” (loc. 1349). C. Matthew McMahon responds: “No, actually, by grace and regeneration a spiritual principle not already present is conferred to the elect, and by faith they are justified through the imputed righteousness of Christ. Baptism is simply a sign of seal [sic] of what already takes place, not a conference of that grace. The Westminster Confession of Faith repudiates Wilson’s position when it distinguishes in this light those who enter the visible church and those who are partakers of the Covenant of Grace as the elect.” C. Matthew McMahon, “The Black List—‘Reformed’ Is Not Enough,” A Puritan’s Mind, November 4, 2011, archived June 18, 2025, https://web.archive.org/web/20250618063251/https://www.apuritansmind.com/book-reviews/the-black-list-reformed-is-not-enough/. Wilson also tries to twist the apostle Peter’s words so that it appears that he also taught baptismal regeneration by explicitly using the word “water” when Peter did not. Wilson writes, “Water baptism now saves us. Peter tells us that baptism saves, and his subsequent qualifier does not mean that baptism does not save. He is not taking away with one hand what he has given with the other. It means that baptism saves in this fashion, but not in that fashion. Baptism does not save by means of the water (not putting away physical dirt), but baptism does save by the resurrection of Jesus Christ accompanied by the answer of a good conscience.” Wilson, “Reformed” Is Not Enough, loc. 1231. For an explanation of the use of “baptism” in 1 Peter 3:18–22 see https://heidelblog.net/2009/04/does-baptism-save/; https://learn.ligonier.org/devotionals/baptism-and-salvation; and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j_6_vtfrxZk. It is important to note, as Peter Davids does of 1 Peter 3:21: “With this reference Peter both draws the readers’ experience close to that of Noah and produces one of the most difficult verses in the NT.” Peter H. Davids, The First Epistle of Peter, The New International Commentary on the New Testament (Eerdmans, 1990), 143. ↩

  9. Full context: “In this Calvinistic sense, baptism offers a twofold grace: forgiveness of sins and regeneration. In this limited sense, we can say that Calvin held to baptismal regeneration. But he also believed in the effectual call, and he knew (being a good Calvinist, perhaps even the best) that this effectual call could precede or follow the moment of baptism.” Wilson, “Reformed” Is Not Enough, loc. 459. But Wilson’s use of Calvin in this way has been condemned by others: “Calvin, Zwingli, Bucer, Capito, Turretin, Vermigli, Ames, Sibbes, Goodwin, Owen, Manton, Hodge, Warfield, and most of the Reformed orthodoxy up and until the Enlightenment believed that the infants of believers were already adopted by God before baptism, and that the parent, in faith of presuming upon God’s promise and command, baptized the child. That did not mean the child was infallibly saved, but that the parent presumed that God’s promises applied to the child. This position for the bulk of the magisterial Reformers, Puritans and framers of the Westminster Confession of Faith is not hard to prove. However, Wilson goes beyond this. For Wilson there is a great amount of redefinition and addition to the Reformers, Puritans and the Westminster Confession of Faith than any of them intended. And none of them, no matter how subtly Wilson attempts to ‘back up’ his information with the Westminster Confession of Faith, believed the same theological formulations as Wilson, or any of the Auburn Four.” McMahon, “The Black List—‘Reformed’ Is Not Enough.” ↩

  10. Charles Haddon Spurgeon, “Baptismal Regeneration,” in Sermons of Rev. C. H. Spurgeon (Sheldon Blakeman, 1865), 24, archived December 4, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20241204181037/https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/baptismal-regeneration/#flipbook/. ↩

  11. “We deny the common misunderstanding of baptismal regeneration—i.e. that an ‘effectual call’ or rebirth is automatically wrought in the one baptized. Baptism apart from a growing and living faith is not saving, but rather damning.” A Joint Federal Vision Profession, 2007, archived July 10, 2011, https://web.archive.org/web/20110710233937/http://federal-vision.com/resources/joint_FV_Statement.pdf. ↩

  12. Wes White, “Reply to the Joint Federal Vision Profession: Part 7; None Dare Call It ‘Baptismal Regeneration,’” Theonomy Resources, September 12, 2013, archived July 31, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240731205112/https://theonomyresources.blogspot.com/2013/09/reply-to-joint-federal-vision.html. Note that, while Wilson no longer calls himself a Federal Visionist, he still holds to the Joint Federal Vision Statement. See our post “‘I Have Decided’ to ‘Discontinue Identifying Myself’ with ‘Federal Vision’ but I Still ‘Affirm Everything I Signed Off on in the Federal Vision Statement’”. ↩

  13. Presbyterian Church in America, Report of Ad Interim Study Committee on Federal Vision, New Perspective, and Auburn Avenue Theologies, 2007, archived December 11, 2023, https://web.archive.org/web/20231211234041/https://www.pcahistory.org/pca/studies/07-fvreport.pdf, 2234. ↩

  14. Our children no longer attend Logos School. ↩

  15. “History,” Logos School, n.d., archived August 3, 2024, https://web.archive.org/web/20240803023354/https://logosschool.com/about/history/. ↩

  16. “The cut-away branch has no fruit (which is why it was cut away)—but it has had sap (which is why it had to be cut away).” Wilson, “Reformed” Is Not Enough, loc. 1601. And “. . . baptism is our introduction to union with Him.” Wilson, “Reformed” Is Not Enough, loc. 2078. Also in the Joint Federal Vision Statement: “We affirm that God formally unites a person to Christ and to His covenant people through baptism into the triune Name.” A Joint Federal Vision Profession, 2007. I related this story to Wilson when we met, and his answer was that they were soon going to be implementing catechism for the children at his church. ↩

  17. See note 7. ↩

  18. See our post “‘I Have Decided’ to ‘Discontinue Identifying Myself’ with ‘Federal Vision’ but I Still ‘Affirm Everything I Signed Off on in the Federal Vision Statement’”. ↩

Subscribe for Updates

Get all the latest posts directly in your inbox.

You’ll receive an email to confirm your subscription.